...but I quite liked it. I think it was advertised badly so people were expecting a nice action/adventure tale. Which it was, only directed by Terry Gilliam. One word: Brazil. Gilliam makes weird, twisted movies that are visually artsy and way the heck out there. So try to keep an open mind, or just don’t watch it.

What a phenomenally awful movie. There were all these things that really seemed to have nothing to do with the plot, and so by the time it finally started moving along… it was over.

Many flaws, mainly character development, but definately worth consuming once. Just for the set design if nothing else.

Lord have pity on me… I forgot (or blocked it out!) that I sat through this when it first came out, and so was partially subjected to it again last night when my daughter wanted to watch it. Good grief! I groaned in mental anguish about twenty minutes into it and then forced myself to fall asleep. I like Ledger and Damon, and a few of the other actors/actresses too, so then why was this film so painful??

I just rewatched it on TV with my little brother, but when I first saw it on the movies I got really impressed by the visual.

I know this got absolutely slated from a lot of corners, but I personally thought it was a lot of fun. Creepy trees, nasty spiders, and an evil queen all show a pair of con-artists that some fairy tales aren’t make believe!

Could have been better, of course, but it had enough moments to keep me watching.

There were some good moments and good ideas in this film, but overall it was a fiasco. i really loved the work Peter Stormare did in Prison Break but he was totally over the top here. The entire storyline with him and Pryce was totally unnecessary, distracting, and disgusting. i wanted more backstory on the Queen and more love between the brothers and more of the references to fairy tales and more of Angelika’s family. This ended up being seriously befuddled and only a little interesting and redeeming.

I watched it on Halloween night and had to keep pausing to deal with the trick-or-treaters coming to the door. Maybe because it fit the holiday, or maybe because I’m a sword and sorcery fan, I liked this in spite of the flaws others have pointed out. I certainly enjoyed it more than the recent Tales of Narnia movie. The special effects are very kewl, amd I thought Heath Ledger pulled off a great acting job as younger brother Jacob Grimm opposite Matt Damon’s portrayal of Will. This film may not be up to director Terry Gilliam’s best efforts (12 Monkeys, Monty Python and the Holy Grail), but it is certainly worth the rental fee.

Title says it all.

Okay, I fell asleep a half hour before the end of the movie, so this isn’t an accurate rating. But it didn’t hold my attention enough to keep me awake, and the humor was funny, but hard to catch in the movie. I didn’t know much about it going in and I was confused. It was fun to see Matt Damon in that role, though.