Goes to show that you shouldn’t listen to film critics. This movie has been derided as “Erin Brockovich goes to Fargo” but it really isn’t that simplistic.
More than just a retelling of a landmark court case, this movie examines the complexities around the phenomenon of sexual harassment: why it occurs and why it is difficult for victims to pursue their attackers or change the situation.
In the movie, the traditionally male workforce at a large iron mine keenly resent a court decision overturning a company ban on hiring women. Located in an economically depressed rural area of northern Minnesota, the mine jobs are dangerous, but are also some of the best jobs available—and they are hard to come by.
The movie illustrates how normal people can do monstrous things when motivated by fear and provided with vulnerable scapegoats.
The men, afraid their place as breadwinners-and thus their identify—is at stake, take it out on the female workers at the plant—the abuse escalates from unrelenting verbal assault to physical intimidation and then sexual assault. Far from being just the crude blunders of men unaccustomed to working with women, these acts evidence a cruel calculus at work. They want the women to quit and they are using tactics most efficient at intimidating the women and isolating them from each other and from available resources for help.
The movie also highlights how the aggressors target particularly vulnerable women—those with personal histories that harm their standing in the mostly conservative small town community aroundt the mine (a single, divorced mother is the movie’s protagonist).
I think the movie also does good job portraying the nuances of responses from the victims. Many, not wanting to admit the true nature of the abuse, blame other victims for “bringing it on themselves” and for “rocking the boat” by persisting in complaining to company management.
It is an interesting examination of the root causes of situations like these and why change is so hard.
I also found the stark scenes of the cold, Minnesota winter to be a perfect metaphor for the difficulties of life faced by all of the mine workers, their desperation, and the isolation felt by the women there.
The one false note is the very pat courtroom confession scene that wraps up the movie and is too unrealistic.
Other than that, it is a great movie that really made me think.