All Consuming


Items Nhoj consumed in…

August, 2006



  1. Friday 4
    0765342618

    Finished consuming…
    Kiln People (The Kiln Books) — 20 people

    Worth consuming!


  2. Sunday 20
    074348486x

    Finished consuming…
    As You Like It (Folger Shakespeare Library) — 199 people

    Worth consuming!


  3. Tuesday 22
    0312856849

    Finished consuming…
    Rainbows End — 21 people

    Worth consuming!


Entries about these items

    0312856849

    A review of "Rainbows End" — 1 year ago

    WORTH CONSUMING!

    Vernor Vinge’s novel, Rainbows End takes place about 20 years in the future, in 2025. In the novel, this is an era in which the young understand much more about their world than grown-ups do. Old people find themselves going back to “high school” (which is attended by junior high or middle school-aged kids) to learn how to function in this new world.

    One of these people is Robert Gu, a poet and a recovering Alzheimer’s patient, who is lucky enough to regain his mental function through new therapies. Although he has regained his intelligence, he has lost both his poetic ability and his characteristic meanness. He semi-unintentionally gets drawn into a scheme involving the UCSD library and international espionage.

    All of the ubiquitous computing people use in this fictional future scenario is based on something called SHE (Secure Hardware Environment, I think), which is sort of like Trusted Computing. A couple of times in the novel, characters find themselves frustrated by the fact that below a certain level, you can’t change things. Below a certain level (where SHE comes into play—possibly at the OS), there are “no user-modifiable parts inside.” Of course, this restriction is quite different from the neo-DIY/Make Magazine style hardware hacking we see today. It reminds me of those little remote control cars that were all the rage a few Christmases ago. You could “customize” them, which meant snapping off a few pre-designed parts and snapping on other ones. In the novel, SHE allows for far more complex combinations, creating a network effect much like the Internet itself. In this future, people are making creations that don’t make much sense to folks from our time—ubiquitous computing allows possibilities that we cannot yet envision. However, I still get the sense that something is lost when hackers give up the ability to modify their OS or below.

    A related geek reference—I found it rather hard to believe that:

    1. the GNU Hurd kernel is released by 2025.
    2. it’s illegal—someone uses a contraband “HurdOS” box in the novel.

    Anyway, I definitely recommend this book—I enjoyed both the tech and the humanity of this near-future tale.

    074348486x

    A story about "As You Like It (Folger Shakespeare Library)" — 1 year ago

    WORTH CONSUMING!

    I read this for the seminar at Stags Leap Wine Cellars. Unfortunately, I think I’m a little out of practice in seminar or maybe I was always that way and just don’t remember. Anyway, I noticed myself thinking that we were approaching the book in the wrong way. I tried to articulate my concerns but they came out all wrong: I said maybe we shouldn’t take the play so seriously but my comment was interpreted to mean that it wasn’t worth analyzing. That’s not really what I meant.

    Fifteen years away from the Program gave me some sense of how transparent the ideological underpinnings are for some people. Someone actually brought up Plato’s divided line. I feel like someone brought up that metaphor in every darn seminar! I felt like taunting that guy and saying, “No! Shakespeare was not thinking of Plato’s divided line when he wrote As You Like It.”

    Another person brought up Plato’s noble lie (was I in the wrong seminar?) and said that most of the problems in the world were caused by people of lesser quality (or some similar elitist description) having power. Did I not notice this kind of elitism when I was at St. John’s or was I just lucky enough to have seminar with a more democratically-minded group?

    0765342618

    A review of "Kiln People (The Kiln Books)" — 1 year ago

    WORTH CONSUMING!

    As a detective story, this novel is pretty good. However, where it really shines is in the premise, a world in which people can create “dittos,” or expendable clay copies of themselves. The copies last one day and then their memories can be uploaded into the original’s mind.

    Anyway, the idea that I really liked was that of the “standing wave,” the metaphor characters in this novel use to describe continuity of consciousness. This idea really makes clear the distinction between self and memory. That is, another entity could share my memories and appear to be me. However, if this being did not continue my standing wave, didn’t continue my original consciousness, it wouldn’t really be me.

    The standing wave varies from person to person. Since the dittos are offshoots of the original, their memories can be uploaded. However, one cannot upload someone else’s dittos memories because, as it turns out, every person’s experience of reality is totally different. The ditto’s memories would be nonsense.

    Anyway, I have been trying to come up with a suitable explanation for why I have a problem with SF technologies like the transporter in Star Trek or with Kurzweil-style “uploading.” The standing wave metaphor really makes it clear. If it breaks or interrupts the standing wave, my copy isn’t really me!


FAQ | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | | Robot Co-op Blog | Copyright © 2004 - 2008 Robot Co-op